One AI Song Doesn't Make the Whole Game Slop
Indie devs who disclose minimal AI use get their whole game called AI slop. The pro-AI side answers with "virtue signaling" and talk of lying on disclosures. Neither helps.

What I keep seeing
Lately I’ve been reading Reddit posts where indie devs show their games. Some of them add an AI disclosure saying they used AI for something minimal, and the replies write themselves: “AI slop.” “I will not play your game until you remove that.”
The clearest example I found is Mend, a fly-fishing game set on real rivers in Alberta and British Columbia. Its developer has been writing software for 20 years and built it alone with Claude. He filled in Steam’s AI disclosure honestly: the narrator and character voices are AI text-to-speech (the characters speak an invented gibberish language), much of the text was written with an AI assistant and then edited by him, and the menu song came from an AI music tool. No image generators. The 3D world, characters and store art are generated by the game’s own code from real elevation and river data, and the birds and rivers are field recordings.
He posted it to several subreddits. The fishing subs talked about fishing. Everywhere else, the disclaimer became the thread: “Ditch the AI and I’ll play it.” “Makes it an easy avoid.”
He also did the math on replacing it. Voice actors for about 22 minutes of lines, plus a composer for one track, would cost around $2,000 USD by his best estimate, and many quotes were above $5,000. The game sells for $13.99. And every tutorial line he reworks after player feedback would cost money again, where today it costs nothing.
If this song is AI, the rest is AI too
Some people go further. They see that one song was generated and decide everything else must be generated as well. Under Mend, someone wrote that even the models and animations were AI. They aren’t: they come from the game’s code and real terrain data. Another commenter said one AI asset usually means there are many more beyond the disclosure. As the developer put it, the disclaimer makes people assume it.
So work that people made by hand gets called AI slop, only because it sits next to one AI asset.
This radicalism is what set me off.
The other side isn’t calmer
The developer then took the question to r/ClaudeAI: what is reasonably expected of a solo dev with no budget? The answers there were just as absolute, only in the other direction. The subreddit’s bot summarized the consensus as calling the backlash a virtue-signaling witch hunt, and a significant number of people said he shouldn’t have disclosed at all.
What is virtue signaling? It means stating a moral position in public mainly to look good to others, not because you intend to act on it. The term is almost always used as an accusation: calling a complaint virtue signaling says the person doesn’t really care and is only showing off.
One commenter called being anti-AI the most virtue signaling stance they had ever seen, said those people’s opinions could be written off as useless, and added that they were all for lying on AI disclosures. A reply agreed: dogmatic tribalism.
Further down, someone pushed back with a specific point. Here AI wasn’t used as a tool, it replaced voice acting, and plenty of indie games ship with no voices at all. You can disagree, but that isn’t virtue signaling. It’s a concrete complaint about work a person could have been paid for, and the developer had already listed shipping silent as one of his options.
I don’t think it’s fine to lie on AI disclosures. I also don’t think it’s good to criminalise someone because they used AI.
Where I stand
I think the reaction is exaggerated. AI is still a tool. And using it for one small thing doesn’t let anyone undermine or undervalue the hard work behind the rest of the game.
Of course there are people who just prompt a couple of things and ship a shitty game. I’m not talking about that.
For me, slop is when you didn’t give a damn about the game and just prompted: no direction, no care, no sensitivity for the assets.
Most of my own games work the other way around. I have used AI at specific points when I hit a wall while creating Dimenshaper and Hexactly, and I always made sure to understand the code it suggested. However, all the assets, music, sprites, and sound effects were made by humans.
FAQ about AI Disclosures and AI Slop
It means stating a moral position in public mainly to look good to others, not because you intend to act on it. The term is almost always used as an accusation, to say that someone does not really care about the issue.
Share article

